All reports

Complex teacher layouts: passing and failing

Run 1 · October 6 · Ten highest-block-count passing and ten failing completed attempts with drawings. “Passing” means recorded automated acceptance, not expert approval. Failure images show the author's submitted revision; independent reread results below determine acceptance. Attempts without drawings are excluded. This deliberately complex sample is not a success-rate estimate.

Passing · 10

t8_profile_01098d50

69 blocks · 2× SJ 0.452 · edge ratio 6.210 · 18.9 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

cells round each hole (box + level-loop rings), wall wedges on the rounds, straight cuts carried on x=33.9, 64.5, 74, 99.58

Revision 3 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_011291e8

52 blocks · 2× SJ 0.405 · edge ratio 5.454 · 11.2 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

base: boxes round holes 1,3,4 on shared grid lines; R2 radial sector + 5-block ring round hole 2; R3 ring round R0 (one block)

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_block_0403c4d8

51 blocks · 2× SJ 0.365 · edge ratio 6.125 · 15.3 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

R1 on top with box round hole 2, wrap block on the round, hole 1 ring across the level line, hole 3 and hole 4 rings, R0 boxed so the fill gets its 4 corners, grid-like lower half

Revision 1 · M · stepped / layered

t8_profile_011abbc0

50 blocks · 2× SJ 0.363 · edge ratio 8.174 · 11.1 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

d3: ring rings, K left split, pockets left to fill

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_01040b28

48 blocks · 2× SJ 0.353 · edge ratio 9.130 · 21.5 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

grid-ish blocks: sector/notch cluster at upper left, reverse O-grid on H1 and H2 boxes, H3 ring to the chamfer round, slot drawn as eight blocks with a ring of neighbours, corner round in its own pair of blocks

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_block_040566d0

47 blocks · 2× SJ 0.462 · edge ratio 4.327 · 5.5 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

grid with reverse O-grid rings round hole and both pockets; lens and pockets cut by fill

Revision 1 · M · stepped / layered

t8_profile_01151e40

47 blocks · 2× SJ 0.353 · edge ratio 9.103 · 13.8 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

grid with ring cells round pockets, hole, slot; O-grid in left lug; fan round right pocket; pockets left to fill

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_010b1fa8

34 blocks · 2× SJ 0.423 · edge ratio 6.905 · 28.2 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

rings round holes 2,3,1, ring round the pocket, rows to the right round; vertical lines x=34.3, 60.6, 86.5, 170.6

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_010318f8

33 blocks · 2× SJ 0.439 · edge ratio 11.718 · 16.3 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: True

hole2 ring of 5 to a box; boss as O-grid (4 + core); R1 one block; R0 five radial blocks; coarse base blocks

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_010b3b00

32 blocks · 2× SJ 0.397 · edge ratio 6.523 · 13.8 min

Recorded strict + refinement + audit acceptance

Checks and author note

judge_failed: []; harness_failed: []; counted_why: []; strict: True; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: True; occupancy: None

straight cuts at outline junction levels; boxed circle and slot holes; radial cuts from convex round midpoints to the round's centre; 45 degree cuts at the concave round

Revision 1 · F · single profile

Failing · 10

t8_profile_01068fb0

67 blocks · 2× SJ 0.489 · edge ratio 20.313 · 19.5 min

Element aspect-ratio check failed

Checks and author note

judge_failed: ['ar_ok']; harness_failed: ['D']; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: False; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: False; occupancy: True

rings round holes and boss, R3 ring, stadium ring, end-round wrap; regions 0 and 2 left to the fill

Revision 2 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_0103c4d8

41 blocks · 2× SJ 0.408 · edge ratio 12.104 · 25.4 min

Element aspect-ratio check failed; Geometry capture check failed

Checks and author note

judge_failed: ['ar_ok', 'capture_ok']; harness_failed: ['D']; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: False; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: False; occupancy: True

R2/R3 drawn as rings, R0 left to the fill (6 loop corners), box ring round hole 1 tied to R2 corners, cuts perpendicular to R0 loop

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_block_04061e68

35 blocks · 2× SJ 0.421 · edge ratio 8.495 · 5.5 min

Element aspect-ratio check failed

Checks and author note

judge_failed: ['ar_ok']; harness_failed: ['D']; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: False; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: False; occupancy: True

annulus in 7 radial sectors; each feature in its own sector with a reverse O-grid to the sector corners; R0 boss left to fill

Revision 1 · M · stepped / layered

t8_profile_011220a0

33 blocks · 2× SJ 0.450 · edge ratio 13.541 · 22.9 min

Element aspect-ratio check failed

Checks and author note

judge_failed: ['ar_ok']; harness_failed: ['D']; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: False; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: False; occupancy: True

left cap fanned from pocket P1 corners to round; slot right end, hole 2 and pocket P0 joined by short radial cuts; P0 drawn as 4-block ring; P1 left to fill

Revision 2 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_010cf468

33 blocks · 2× SJ 0.408 · edge ratio 6.740 · 10.4 min

Element aspect-ratio check failed

Checks and author note

judge_failed: ['ar_ok']; harness_failed: ['D']; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: False; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: False; occupancy: True

row below y=3.9 (slot box, R0 O-grid, R1 O-grid), blocks above; hole 1 ringed to wall/fillet/diag

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_011604b8

29 blocks · 2× SJ — · edge ratio — · 16.6 min

build: the layout fails the 2-D judge: F3:CORNER-SINE,F3:SMOOTH-CORNER>150,F3:TFI-SJ

Checks and author note

judge_failed: None; harness_failed: None; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: None; stable_numbers: False; block_pass: None; audit_pass: False; occupancy: None

pocket drawn, lens left to fill, pentagon ring round hole

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_011a42a8

29 blocks · 2× SJ — · edge ratio — · 16.3 min

build: the layout fails the 2-D judge: F0:CORNER-SINE,F0:TFI-SJ

Checks and author note

judge_failed: None; harness_failed: None; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: None; stable_numbers: False; block_pass: None; audit_pass: False; occupancy: None

R1 U-pocket in 3 blocks round hole-2 top; R0 left to the fill; R2 ring round hole 1 plus grid, hole-2 lower ring

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_010b42d0

22 blocks · 2× SJ 0.417 · edge ratio 14.798 · 18.4 min

Geometry capture check failed

Checks and author note

judge_failed: ['capture_ok']; harness_failed: []; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: False; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: False; occupancy: True

d6: corner on O3 too

Revision 3 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_0113c298

19 blocks · 2× SJ 0.439 · edge ratio 12.705 · 19.7 min

Geometry capture check failed

Checks and author note

judge_failed: ['capture_ok']; harness_failed: []; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: False; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: False; occupancy: True

R0 as 3 blocks, R1 left to fill; base fanned from hole to line corners, right bulge as radial band blocks around a core

Revision 2 · F · stepped / layered

t8_profile_01153d80

16 blocks · 2× SJ 0.600 · edge ratio 7.619 · 6.7 min

Geometry capture check failed

Checks and author note

judge_failed: ['capture_ok']; harness_failed: []; counted_why: ['STRICT']; strict: False; stable_numbers: True; block_pass: True; audit_pass: False; occupancy: True

pocket own block; quarter-round fillets isolated in own quads; axis cuts from pocket sides

Revision 1 · F · stepped / layered

Enlarged layout